Tuesday, 4 August 2015
Is this the worst Government ever?
Sally Young looks at Abbott's legislative record in today's SMH
http://www.smh.com.au/comment/is-tony-abbotts-regime-the-worst-federal-government-ever-20150803-giqtnx.html
Republican Presidential Debate Time Is Here!
Why the
Republican Party Can't Win
I have a
confession to make. I'm a political junkie. I find the world around
me and the people in it endlessly fascinating. Trying to understand
why our society is the way it is keeps me up at night. Then there are
the things that bring me joy. One of those is about to begin.
The debates
between candidates for the Republican party nomination begin on
August 6th. It's a circus. It's like watching the a train
crash in slow motion. This year we have the clown in chief (Donald
Trump) who will be trying to out wacky some of weirdest and wackiest
candidates the Grand Old Party (GOP) have ever thrown together.
The
contrast between the Republican debates and the Democratic debates is
as fascinating as it is informative. Democratic debates are filled
with sensible earnest looking people putting on their serious face
and explaining how their 4,500 page tax plan is the good for the
nation. Republicans on the other hand will just scream that the
Internal Revenue Service (IRS) who collects tax is in everybody's face and when elected President I'll abolish it. And the crowd goes
wild!
As amusing
as it is, it's indicative of a larger fact. Republican's cant win.
The most obvious reason, is that American demographics have changed
and are continuing to change. Since 1992 Republican candidates have
legitimately won one election presidential election. That of 2004. The
election of 2000, was so close, that it was called before all the
votes were counted. It turns out, that after all the votes were
counted, Al Gore, not George Bush won the state of Florida and
therefore should have been declared president. 2004 was an anomaly
due to the Iraq war.
How did
it come to this?
America
continues to diversify. In the 2012 presidential election 26.3 % of
voters were non-white, up 2 % from 2008.. That doesn't sound like
much, but consider that Obama won that particular segment by 80% -
17% for Mitt Romney and you can see that the GOP has a real problem.
In fact after the 2012 election defeat the Republican National
Committee (RNC) postmortem
opened with the words:
“The
definition of insanity, is doing the same thing over and over again
and expecting different results."
Sadly
nothing has changed since 2012.
Immigration
Latino (or
Spanish speaking) voters are the second largest minority in the USA
after African Americans. They make up 20 million eligible voters.
They tend to be 1st or 2nd generation immigrants to
america. The immigration programme is something they're quite
familiar with. When Republican candidates talk about immigration,
however they tend to do so in unflattering terms. Such as:
" When
Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re
not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people
that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems
with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re
rapists." -
Donald
Trump June 2015
Insanity
While
it's obvious to anyone that insulting the voters you need for the
general election is insane, it has to be done. The reason is that of
course anyone running a line that is remotely palatable to voters in
the general election simply can't win the Republican Party
nomination.
But
Why?
I
think there are a 3 major reasons for this. The first we'll call the
Echo Chamber Effect.
Echo
Chamber Effect?
One
of the most unexpected effects of the information revolution was the
echo chamber effect. People were now free to gain information about
the world around them from only the sources they believed in. People
no longer sat down together to watch the evening news. News could be
had from anywhere and from anyone. People didn't choose the
mainstream media anymore, they wanted news they agreed with all the
time.
This
was the perfect time for Rupert Murdoch to start Fox News. Fox News
is the most brazen partisan news organisation there has been, and
probably ever will be. Fox News truly lives in an alternate universe
where Barack Obama is a communist born in Kenya. They employ circular
logic to brainwash viewers in exactly the same way a cult does. Any
information (such as this blog) that does not agree with Fox is a
product of the evil liberal media. Therefore it is rejected, which
feeds the belief in Fox and the conservative media.
Amusingly
(and frighteningly) it isn't just voters who become brainwashed by
this nonsense. Karl Rove simply refused to believe Obama had been
elected in 2012. Why? All the polls pointed to a Romney win. This doesn't make sense. Except it makes perfect sense, because Fox was
lying about the polls and had been for months. His meltdown is
amusing in a sad kind of way and you can watch it here:
Powerful
Republicans are just as likely to fall into this alternate universe
as the white working class voters who make up the majority of their
constituency. It's an Orwellian place where facts have no meaning, change constantly or are ignored if not helpful to the republican
cause. But the biggest problem about the echo chamber, is that Republicans have started to believe their own propaganda.
The
Gerrymander Effect?
The USA has
no independent umpire when it comes to drawing electoral boundaries.
Gerrymandering is drawing the political boundaries for political
gain. The original Gerrymander was enacted by Massachusetts
Governor Elbridge Gerry in 1812 and looked like a salamander.
What
happens is that both parties get together to group all voters of one
party together to create a safe seat. Both party's benefit from this
practice by reducing the amount of seats "in play" so that
finite party resources can be spent on fewer and fewer marginal
districts. Unfortunately in the USA today the House of Representatives
has extremely few contested districts.
The average
Congressman sits in a very safe seat. The public are extremely unlikely
to throw him or her out. On the other hand, they must listen very
closely to those in their party. If they become unpopular, they will
lose the right to stand for their party. Their party who are caught
up in this alternate universe where reality and facts do not tread.
It leads to Congressman denouncing global warming as a devious plot
designed to bring back socialism or whatever claptrap the echo
chamber is reverberating with today. I would like to remind you that
these people make policy decisions that effect not just America but
their footprint echos throughout the 7.3 BILLION humans on planet
Earth.
Free Trade
Effect
Republican
voters in America today tend to be the lesser educated manual
laborers. Salt of the Earth people like miners, plumbers and
manufacturing workers. These are the people who have suffered from
overseas competition. Competition from economies that have far lower
wages.. Real wages among the working and middle class in America
haven't risen in 40 years.
It's always
during difficult economic times that the far right raises its ugly
head. As Americans lives fail to get better, people need someone to
blame. According to the right wing eco-chamber it's Obama. But of
course it's also immigration.
The
American right has tied a Gordian Knot for itself. To break out of
the echo chamber is damn near impossible. 4 years ago Mitt Romney
didn't even try. Will Someone manage it this year?
Governor
Jeb Bush
Not Jeb
Bush who has put together the same team his brother had. So expect
America to invade Belgium if he's ever elected. But of course he wont
be. Being brother to the WORST AMERICAN PRESIDENT in a
generation is a handicap he can't beat.
Governor
Chris Christie
Current
Goveror of New Jersey. Too moderate (sensible) for most Republican
voters, but if by some miracle he is nominated might make a good
opponent for Hillary, and a POSSIBLE GOOD PRESIDENT.
Could be the one to untie the Gordian Knot.
Senator
Ted Cruz
Political
bomb thrower. GOD HELP AMERICA if he's ever elected
Governor
Scott Walker
RIGHT
WING IDEALOG. Current Governor of Wisconson. My Personal Pick for
the nomination. I think he'll win the nomination, run against Hillary
and lose.
Dr Ben
Carsen
GROUND
BREAKING NEUROSURGEON.
Currently polling well. African American. A dark horse.
Governor
Mike Huckabee
Former
Governor of Arkansas, CHRISTIAN ACTIVIST and
FOX NEWS PERSONALITY
Governor Mike Huckabee. He's likable enough but definitely wont be the
nominee. As a Fox News Talking Head, he cant break the Republican
Party free of the echo chamber.
Senator
Marco Rubio
CUBAN
AMERICAN Marco Rubio from
Florida is an impressive orator and could portray a more welcoming
America in the general election. Which is why he won't win the
nomination. An acolyte of Jeb Bush, he's handicapped by Bush's run as
well. Possible untier of that Gordian Knot.
Senator
Rand Paul
SON
OF SENATOR
RON PAUL, Rand has made his
mark as a Libertarian Candidate. He's a bit of a political bomb
thrower and far too unorthodox to be in real contention. Doesnt live
in the echo chamber, therefore has little credibility to those inside
it.
Governor
John Kasich
Current
Governor of Ohio, former member of the House of Representatives and
former FOX NEWS PERSONALITY.
Definitely wont break the echo chamber.
Donald
Trump
Property
magnate and Reality
TV Star Donald Trump is a 21st
Century PT Barnum. The
circus is in town and he is the ringmaaster and head clown. His ties
to the Clinton's will be exploited if he continues to lead in the
polls. He revels in controversy. All the serious candidates are
waiting for him to screw up and burn out.
The
Clown
So
we return to where we began. Donald Trump's popularity is a symptom
of the sickness and depravity of the echo chamber world of right wing
politics in the USA right now. While democrats chuckle to themselves
about how this election is a shoe-in, the rest of America and the
world aren't laughing. Candidates who could challenge the Democrats
and make good Presidents are left by the roadside while morons and
idiots hurl invective around insulting everyone who isn't white,
straight and christian. It's quite the spectacle, but a healthy
democracy needs at least two strong parties. What we have here is one
party who aren't even trying (Clinton again) vs a drunk, disorderly
knife fight. Americas problems that need addressing that don't go away.
They just get shelved as too hard.
Sunday, 2 August 2015
Bronwyn Bishop Expenses Scandal
What the
Bronwyn Bishop Scandal Says About Both Sides of Government
So Bronwyn
Bishop has finally resigned from the Speakership of the Parliament of
Australia. Thank goodness that's over. Being Speaker of the House was
always an ambition for Bronnie, after a senior cabinet post became
out of the question. Her points of order objections were the stuff of
legend among those who inhabit the lower chamber.
One can
understand then her reluctance to leave her position, it comes with a
very nice residence, plenty of perks and makes you feel important.
But the lasting impression that I have is that had she been sensible,
she would still been speaker.
First of
all there is the actual expenses claim. $5000 on a Helicopter ride
when it really must have only saved 45 minutes at the most is
ridiculous. But lets not forget the $90,000 European trip aimed at
securing the Presidency of the Inter-Parliamentary Union.
Then there
is claims to attend the weddings of colleagues where Parliamentary
business was discussed with shadowy somebodies we cant know.
The rules
are crystal clear. Party and personal business cannot be claimed.
Commonwealth business can. Simples.
Of course
these were bad. But not intolerable.
Secondly
and I think more importantly was her (and the govt's) response to the
scandal when it erupted. After a few days she fronted the media and
refused to say sorry. She did say the biggest apology she could make
is that she would pay back the money, but then claimed that she was
on Commonwealth business talking to people as Speaker of the House.
The fact that these people were Liberal Party doners went unsaid.
This was fraud. Pure fraud. Had she said "The helicopter ride
was wrongly classified and exorbitant. I'm repaying it, I made a
mistake." She would still be speaker today. Instead she accepted
no responsibility.
Thirdly
this was a massive case of Bronwyn and Tony's chickens coming home to
roost. It was Tony's opposition that mercilessly pursued the last
Speaker of the House Peter Slipper. A man who was sentenced to 300
hrs of community service, given a 2 year good behavior bond and told
to repay his $958 expenses claim on Cabcharge.
Bronwyn's
conduct as speaker also contributed to the the force with which Labor
pursued Mrs Bishop. The Speaker was unfair and divisive. She kindled
genuine anger in those opposite. Therefore when the expenses scandal
broke Labor (who have a vested interest in voters not paying too
close attention to politicians expenses) decided to attack fully.
There is a
disturbing trend in the last 8 years in Australia for politicians to
ignore the big picture. This was pioneered by Kevin Rudd. John Howard
had an overall narrative. He maintained that interest rates would
always be lower under Liberal than Labor. He wanted everything he did
and said to be interpreted through that lens. This is where Kevin,
Julia and Tony have all failed. They play the 24hr media cycle. If
you have more positive coverage in a given period of time than the
other side you win. But with no long term plan, the small gains mean
very little. Hugely popular PM's can fall quickly and hard.(eg PM
Rudd.). The genius of Howard's approach is that even unpopular
actions were interpreted through a lens created by Howard himself. It
creates robust political support. What we have now is a bunch of
private school prefects arguing over unimportant nonsense that is
completely removed from everyday Australia's life.
It's a
"Total War" approach to politics which eschews common sense
and reason, boiling political life down to a Real Time Strategy video
game. But we aren't just units on a battlefield to be ordered,
rallied, cajoled or sacrificed. We have lives, homes, children, hopes
and dreams.
John Howard, Paul Keating, Robert Menzies et.al understood this. They reasoned that as human beings we needed to trust our leaders. They outlined their vision for Australia and advocated powerfully for their ideas.
Contrast that with todays generation of politicians. Explain to me Bill Shorten's vision for Australia. Or Tony Abbott's for that matter. They don't have one. They just grind on bit by bit day by day with minutia. Don't give an inch. Don't let them push you back. But none of it means anything.
Bronwyns
way of dealing with her public sinning is indicative of this new
culture. "Give them nothing". Nothing that could be
construed as an apology. Especially if that is what is called for.
The problem with this approach, is that it forgets who the message is
aimed at. We the public can detect bullshit. And Bronnies confession
without confessing stank. Bigtime.
So to any
politicians or political staff reading this. Your culture is
terrible. Wake up to yourself. You're not fooling us, just reminding
us how we despise liars and removing hope for the future.
Saturday, 1 August 2015
Friday, 31 July 2015
The Adam Goodes Controversy - what's really going on?
Adam
Goodes Controversy – What's really going on here?
I have a
confession to make. I don't like Australian Rules Football. The first
9 year of my life were spent in Punchbowl in Sydney where Rugby
League was king and the Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs were Gods. The
Mortimer brothers were my sporting hero's growing up.
In time my
family moved to the St George area but I didn't lose my love of the
blue and whites. My first sporting memory is of the 1979 grand final
where St George beat Canterbury. I was 4 years old and devastated.
An Indigenous Football Player
Now I'm no
stranger to booing players, in my Rugby League following days I used
to boo Anthony Mundine. Anthony Mundine is an indigenous man who I
felt at the time had an ego that had to be heard to be believed. I
used to joke that Anthony Mundine couldn't make the game today
because he was detained by a full length mirror.
In my more
lucid moments if pushed I would have told you that Anthony Mundine
was an excellent player and to break him psychologically on the field
would give my team a match winning edge. I would also have told you
that in no way was my booing of Mundine racist. I would have believed
it when i told you that too, but 20 years later i can now understand
that what I resented was an unaustralian (as i saw it) way of
relating to fans, players and sponsors in professional sport. I
disliked him because he didn't act like a product of my culture where
humility is valued in its Sportsmen.
Men like
Mark Taylor, Peter Sterling and even Sir Donald Bradman were grounded
in this more humble culture. When Mundine came along saying I'm the
greatest play-maker in the world, I found him offensive.
She Called him What?
The current
controversy surrounding Adam Goodes is driving the media into a
frenzy. I think we need to take a step back and get some context.
In 2013
during the Australian Football League's (AFL) Indigenous round, Adam
Goodes (playing for the Sydney Swans) was called an ape by a 13 year
old female supporter of Carlton. Goodes told officials what had
happened and pointed the fan out. She was subsequently ejected from
the arena. This news report from the seven network shows the
incident.
The
perpetrator of the abuse was indeed a 13 year old girl. Goodes gave a
thoughtful and heartfelt press conference the next day. He said he
did not blame her, but that society needed to be educated.
The
Collingwood fan did call him after the press conference as he
announced on twitter
"Just
received a phone call from a young girl apologizing for her actions.
Lets support her please#racismitstopswithme #IndigenousRound
"
- Adam Goodes (@adamroy37) May 25, 2013
So what
should Goodes have done? Should he indeed have called out the racist
taunt or ignored it? Many Australians feel he should have ignored the
girl because she was so young. He even admitted that she could not
have understood how the taunt would be understood by him.
To that I
say BULLSHIT! Should minorities all over Australia be subject to
racism because people don't know any better? Of course not. It doesn't
matter if you are 13 or 93, racism is wrong and should be called out.
To ignore
the girl would be to accept the status quo. To call her out would be
to cause considerable trouble for her on that night, but remember she
did call him an ape. That is a clearly racist statement.
The problem
for Goodes though is that he tripped one of the unconscious nerves
in white Australia's subconscious. That of the black man dominating
the white woman. To make it worse she was 13, not even a woman.
That's how it started.
So from
then on Goodes was booed whenever he touched the ball. He was called
a sook, because he couldn't take being called names.
This year
during the AFL's indigenous round (the jerseys, the ball, etc were
all themed Aboriginal) Goodes was receiving boos from the Carlton
supporters. So after he kicked an aboriginal themed ball through an
aboriginal themed goal wearing an aboriginal themed jersey he did an
aboriginal themed wardance as celebration. Here's the video:
EVERYONE
LOSES THEIR MIND!!!!
What ever
happened to sport as entertainment! That was awesomely entertaining
and in the best tradition of crowd/player interaction. Frankly I
wouldn't have been surprised if Goodes had walked up to the TV camera
at the end of the match and yelled "ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED!!!!"
Now Goodes
isn't the first sportsman or woman to have a go at the crowd after
scoring a goal, but of course as the 1st aboriginal player
to do so, Goodes tripped another unconscious nerve. The angry black
man.
Australia
tends to be a tolerant and accepting society, minority figures are
embraced and loved. People like Christine Anu, Ernie Dingo, Ahn Doe,
to name just a few. However that minority figure must not question
the status quo. Minorities should be grateful for the country we
provide for them.
Of
course that the riches we enjoy were indeed hard won, they were hard
won from another people. Those people are still here, and when they
(the aboriginal people) remind us of that fact, and that they have a
powerful, distinct, ancient culture white Australia loses the plot.
So Adam
Goodes is an (unconsciously scary) sook. He needs to calm down and
stop bullying the Carlton supporters and that poor white girl.
Bullshit.
White
Australia has 228 years of keeping the black man down. white Australia systematically dispossessed and then ethnically cleansed black Australia. white Australia attempted genocide. Frankly
Aboriginal Australia has been more forgiving than we would be under
the same circumstances.
Herein lies
the problem for white Australia. Many in this country find it
difficult to come to terms with the genocide perpetrated by our
ancestors on Mr Goodes ancestors. It's a difficult journey.
It's a
journey that I 20 years ago on the sidelines at Kogarah Oval booing
Anthony Mundine had not yet embarked on. It's why one half of white
australia looks at the other half and says "stop being so goddam
racist" while the other half who haven't made the journey yet
look back in horror and say: "I'm not racist, the big scary
black man threatened me". They don't understand their own
triggers.
One final
thing, if you are hit by Adam Goodes imaginary spear, lie still until
the imaginary paramedics come to your aid and take you to imaginary
hospital.
YA BUNCH OF SOOKS!
A.Russell
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)